SciPost Submission Page
From combinatorial maps to correlation functions in loop models
by Linnea GransSamuelsson, Jesper Lykke Jacobsen, Rongvoram Nivesvivat, Sylvain Ribault, Hubert Saleur
This is not the latest submitted version.
This Submission thread is now published as
Submission summary
Authors (as registered SciPost users):  Linnea GransSamuelsson · Jesper Lykke Jacobsen · Rongvoram Nivesvivat · Sylvain Ribault 
Submission information  

Preprint Link:  https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08168v1 (pdf) 
Date submitted:  20230510 21:21 
Submitted by:  Ribault, Sylvain 
Submitted to:  SciPost Physics 
Ontological classification  

Academic field:  Physics 
Specialties: 

Approach:  Theoretical 
Abstract
In twodimensional statistical physics, correlation functions of the O(N) and Potts models may be written as sums over configurations of nonintersecting loops. We define sums associated to a large class of combinatorial maps (also known as ribbon graphs). We allow disconnected maps, but not maps that include monogons. Given a map with n vertices, we obtain a function of the moduli of the corresponding punctured Riemann surface. Due to the map's combinatorial (rather than topological) nature, that function is singlevalued, and we call it an npoint correlation function. We conjecture that in the critical limit, such functions form a basis of solutions of certain conformal bootstrap equations. They include all correlation functions of the O(N) and Potts models, and correlation functions that do not belong to any known model. We test the conjecture by counting solutions of crossing symmetry for fourpoint functions on the sphere.
Current status:
Reports on this Submission
Report 2 by Bernard Nienhuis on 2023727 (Invited Report)
 Cite as: Bernard Nienhuis, Report on arXiv:2302.08168v1, delivered 20230726, doi: 10.21468/SciPost.Report.7566
Strengths
1) The definition of the combinatorial maps is very clear and systematic, and helpfully enlightened with examples.
2) The results are are significant progress in the understanding of correlation functions in loop models.
Weaknesses
1) While the approach is clearly stated, it is not clear where it comes from. The role of combinatorial maps for the definition of correlation functions seems to appear out of nowhere.
Report
Much information about the universal properties of the ordering phase transitions in socalled Potts and O(N) models in two dimensions has been obtained by the study of loop models, of which the states are configurations of loops in the plane. These loop configurations are intrinsically invariant under the global symmetry groups, the permutation group of Q elements and the rotation group in N dimensions respectively. As a result the action and representations of these symmetry groups are not at all obvious in terms of these loop models.
The authors of the present paper together with several others make an effort to clarify this problem in a series of recent papers: the current paper and its references [1], [3], [4] and [5].
This paper addresses the problem of correlation functions. It sets up a intricate way of defining different correlation functions based on combinatorial maps. Each (weakly connected) combinatorial map corresponds to one unique correlation function, i.e. one solution to the bootstrap equations. About the nature of the correlation function the authors say "it is not clear how to interpret it as a correlation function of local fields". It sounds as if it is a complete mystery. But it seems the authors know much more. I am unable to interpret the text in terms of the relation between the conbinatorial map and the correlation function. When the segments are discussed and the meaning of the angle with which they are incident to a vertex they seem to be related to the height in the height representation of the loop model. But what the relation is, is not made entirely explicit. The relation between the combinatorial map and the Kac classification of the correlated fields does appear to be clear.
While the combinatorial maps are a discrete set, taking into account the angles at which the segments join the vertices, appears to a be continuous defining parameters. it remains unclear to me if this is to be interpreted as a continuous family of correlation functions.
It is helpful that the authors are explicit in the aspects they do not yet know, but wish to know.
In spite of the fact that important aspects of the paper escape me, I do consider it an important and impressive project. In my opinion it deserves to be published in scipost. But I do hope that the unclarites mentioned above can be either resolved or stated explicitly.
Anonymous Report 1 on 2023615 (Invited Report)
 Cite as: Anonymous, Report on arXiv:2302.08168v1, delivered 20230615, doi: 10.21468/SciPost.Report.7358
Report
The O(N) and Potts models are generalizations of the Ising model which play an important role in the theory of critical phenomena. It is known that in two dimensions the Coulomb gas method leads to formulations of these models in terms of nonintersecting loops, and that in these formulations the global symmetries characteristic of the two models  O(N) and permutational, respectively  are no longer easy to identify. The authors of the present paper observe that the role of global symmetry may be similarly difficult to identify when looking for solutions of the crossing symmetry equations within the twodimensional conformal bootstrap for correlation functions at criticality. The idea of the paper is then to propose a framework in which suitably defined correlation functions may provide a basis for solutions of the conformal bootstrap equations; this is pursued without reference to global symmetry, and then without a specific focus on O(N) and Potts models.
The programme is ambitious and several steps are admittedly conjectural. The authors associate a correlation function to a combinatorial map, namely a graph made of vertices and edges, further constrained by a number of requirements designed to make contact with the properties of twodimensional conformal field theory. In particular, the number 2r of edges ending at a vertex and the angular momentum s depending on the angles of the edges at the vertex are associated to the indices r and s labeling conformal dimensions within the Kac parametrization. A correspondence of similar nature is provided on the lattice by the Coulomb gas approach, but the authors hope that their combinatorial definitions make sense of it directly in the continuum. As they recall, it is known that the connectivities of the random cluster model can be mapped onto correlation functions of local fields directly in the continuum.
The arguments developed by the authors lead them to propose identifications between dimensions of spaces of solutions of crossing symmetry equations in theories with specific field contents and numbers of combinatorial maps belonging to suitably chosen sets. Then they use the numerical bootstrap for fourpoint correlation functions to verify that the conjectures are indeed confirmed in a number of cases they can test. They make explicit the conjectural nature of the paper and point out that the numerical verifications they present are limited and that more will be needed.
The paper provides an interesting step in the investigation of a vast and difficult problem. I suggest publication in SciPost.