SciPost Submission Page

Landau Theory for Non-Equilibrium Steady States

by Camille Aron, Claudio Chamon

Submission summary

As Contributors: Camille Aron
Arxiv Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.04777v2 (pdf)
Date accepted: 2020-04-21
Date submitted: 2020-04-15
Submitted by: Aron, Camille
Submitted to: SciPost Physics
Discipline: Physics
Subject area: Statistical and Soft Matter Physics
Approach: Theoretical

Abstract

We examine how systems in non-equilibrium steady states close to a continuous phase transition can still be described by a Landau potential if one forgoes the assumption of analyticity. In a system simultaneously coupled to several baths at different temperatures, the non-analytic potential arises from the different density of states of the baths. In periodically driven-dissipative systems, the role of multiple baths is played by a single bath transferring energy at different harmonics of the driving frequency. The mean-field critical exponents become dependent on the low-energy features of the two most singular baths. We propose an extension beyond mean field.

Ontology / Topics

See full Ontology or Topics database.

Landau levels Steady states

Published as SciPost Phys. 8, 074 (2020)



Author comments upon resubmission

We are grateful to the Referee for his/her in-depth review of the Manuscript. We are pleased that our core results reached him/her in a clear way. The Referee is making pertinent comments and asking insightful questions. We address some of them, while some others go beyond the scope of this first manuscript, and frankly, beyond our current understanding of the full theory we aspire at developing. We included the latter in the last section, "Beyond mean field -- discussion and open problems", and are committed to addressing them in future works.


1) Following the Referee's suggestion, we included a paragraph to give a little more background to the Lindblad equation that is employed to describe the dissipative quantum dynamics. We reproduce this paragraph here below:
"Such Lindblad equations are commonly used to describe the dynamics of quantum systems weakly coupled to an environment. They characterize the non-unitary evolution of the system's reduced density matrix, \textit{i.e.} once the degrees of freedom of the environment have been traced out. They can be derived unambiguously under the Born-Markov approximation (\textit{i.e.} within the same regime of validity as the Fermi Golden rule), assuming the immediate environment is relaxing sufficiently fast to remain unaffected by the state of the system. In the limit of no environment, they reduce to the usual von Neumann equation of isolated dynamics, see the first term in the RHS of Eq. (26). The following terms in the RHS originate from the hybridization with the environment. They involve the quantum of energy exchanged with the environment $\epsilon \equiv 2 |\varphi|$, the Bose-Einstein distribution $n_{\rm B}(\omega, T) \equiv 1/(\rme^{\omega/T}-1) $, the jump operators $\sigma_\varphi^\pm \equiv S^\pm$ when $\varphi > 0$ and $\sigma_\varphi^\pm \equiv S^\mp$ when $\varphi < 0$, and the Lindblad operators $\mathcal{D}[X] \rho \equiv X \rho X^\dagger - (X^\dagger X \rho + \rho X^\dagger X)/2$ that act linearly on the system's density matrix, while preserving its trace, hermiticity, and positivity."


2) Yes indeed, in addition to the non-analytic terms of the Landau potential, the field theory for non-equilibrium steady states could also feature non-analytic terms in the gradient terms. They would be of intrinsic non-equilibrium nature. This question can only be answered rigorously by going beyond the mean-field picture, and by accumulating more knowledge (in particular from brute-force numerical simulations) on the generic properties of the statics of these non-equilibrium steady states.

However, given that we are only working with \emph{local} environments, our initial intuition is that tracing out those degrees of freedom should not contribute explicitly to specific non-equilibrium gradient terms in the field theory.

Having said that, real-space coarse-graining could generate non-analytic gradient terms out of those already present in the potential. In the lack of a full-fledged RG computation to provide a clear-cut answer, we may venture into a simple argument:

- the mean-field approach teaches us that non-analytic terms of the form $|\varphi|^(2+\alpha)$, with $\alpha > 0$, can show up in the Landau potential

- we saw in Sect. 3.3 that these terms could be equivalently absorbed in the definition of a field-dependent, non-analytic, effective temperature $T_{\rm eff}(\varphi)$

- in the event that this effective temperature has any physical meaning beyond its mere definition, it would be natural to envision gradient terms of the form $(\nabla \varphi)^2 / T_{\rm eff}(\varphi)$ (this is motivated, \textit{e.g.}, by the Hubbard-Stratonovich construction of the equilibrium Landau-Ginzburg free-energy which features terms of the form $(\nabla \varphi)^2 / T$). In turn, these would yield non-analytic terms of the form $(\nabla \varphi)^2 |\varphi|^{\alpha}$. Simple power counting seems to indicate that they are less relevant than the initial $(\nabla \varphi)^2$ terms (in an RG sense that still has to be sharpened of course).

We included elements of this discussion in Sect. 5 "Beyond mean field -- discussion and open problems", below the free energy proposed in Eq.~(43).


3) "time-dependent nonequilibrium" can encompass different possible scenarios. While the discussion about generic time-dependent many-body states remains equivocal, we may discuss a couple of simpler scenarios that we feel are relevant.

(a) Slowly-varying non-equilibrium states. Assuming that the relaxation mechanisms are effective enough to allow the system to follow the instantaneous steady state set by the interplay of the drive and the dissipation, we naturally expect that a single-order-parameter description is still valid, simply upgrading $\phi(x)$ to $\phi(x,t)$.

(b) Floquet-type scenarios (i.e. with periodic driving). Here, we indeed expect the need for additional order parameters to describe the periodic steady state. While in this manuscript (e.g. in Sect. 4.2 "Floquet-driven dissipative Ising model") we are only discussing the DC component, i.e. the "zero frequency baseline", we expect that the amplitude of each harmonic $n$ of the periodic steady state should also be described by an order parameter $\phi_n(x)$. There, the field theory would therefore take the form of a Landau-Ginzburg Hamiltonian coupling all the field harmonics. Ultimately, an RG analysis could provide insight into the relevance of the different order parameters.


We also thank the Referee for pointing out the typos and help us clarify the few minor points he/she listed. We modified our manuscript accordingly.

List of changes

- New paragraph below Eq. (26) to give a rapid introduction to Lindblad equations
- New discussion in Section 5 "Beyond mean field -- discussion and open problems" on the possibility of the presence of non-analytic gradient terms in the Landau-Ginzburg free energy
- typos and small clarifications here and there

Submission & Refereeing History

Resubmission 1910.04777v2 on 15 April 2020
Submission 1910.04777v1 on 18 October 2019

Login to report or comment