Processing math: 100%
SciPost logo

SciPost Submission Page

Achieving quantum advantage in a search for a violations of the Goldbach conjecture, with driven atoms in tailored potentials

by Oleksandr V. Marchukov, Andrea Trombettoni, Giuseppe Mussardo, Maxim Olshanii

Submission summary

Authors (as registered SciPost users): Maxim Olshanii
Submission information
Preprint Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00517v3  (pdf)
Date submitted: 2025-03-27 03:18
Submitted by: Olshanii, Maxim
Submitted to: SciPost Physics Core
Ontological classification
Academic field: Physics
Specialties:
  • Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics - Theory
Approach: Theoretical

Abstract

The famous Goldbach conjecture states that any even natural number N greater than 2 can be written as the sum of two prime numbers p(I) and p(II). In this article we propose a quantum analogue device that solves the following problem: given a small prime p(I), identify a member N of a N-strong set even numbers for which Np(I) is also a prime. A table of suitable large primes p(II) is assumed to be known a priori. The device realizes the Grover quantum search protocol and as such ensures a N quantum advantage. Our numerical example involves a set of 51 even numbers just above the highest even classical-numerically explored so far [T. O. e Silva, S. Herzog, and S. Pardi, Mathematics of Computation {\bf 83}, 2033 (2013)]. For a given small prime number p(I)=223, it took our quantum algorithm 5 steps to identify the number N=4×1018+14 as featuring a Goldbach partition involving 223 and another prime, namely p(II)=4×1018239. Currently, our algorithm limits the number of evens to be tested simultaneously to Nln(N): larger samples will typically contain more than one even that can be partitioned with the help of a given p(I), thus leading to a departure from the Grover paradigm.

Author comments upon resubmission

Our referee remarks inspired us to, effectively, rewrite the paper and run a series of computer simulations, for which we are indefinitely grateful.

  1. We modified the protocol in such a way that it is now isomorphic to the conventional Grover search scheme. Extensive literature exists that studies the efficiency of the latter.

  2. We underwent an extensive numerical experimentation cycle and found an optimal set of system parameters

2b. On the negative side, our numerical study showed that the requirements to the relative values of the perturbation matrix elements, for both omega- and s-gates, are much more stringent than we expected. While the unperturbed Hamiltonian remains firmly rooted in potentials realized in Donatella Cassettari's lab, the gate perturbations used in our numerics are represented by their idealized versions. More work is needed to bring our proposal in contact with the AMO reality. Our recent AVS Quantum [O. V. Marchukov and M. Olshanii, AVS Quantum Science 7, 013801 (2025)]is a step in this direction.

  1. The text is completely rewritten.

  2. Our introduction is substantially extended.

List of changes

Major changes

1. We added numerical simulations.
2. The protocol is mildly altered: in the most recent version, even numbers and large primes correspond to the quantum eigenstates and small primes are perturbation frequencies. As the result, the protocol is now identical to the Grover one.
3. Overall, the text has been very substantially rewritten.

Current status:
Refereeing in preparation

Login to report or comment