SciPost Submission Page
Quasiperiodic Quadrupole Insulators
by Raul Liquito, Miguel Gonçalves, Eduardo V. Castro
This is not the latest submitted version.
This Submission thread is now published as
Submission summary
Authors (as registered SciPost users): | Raul Liquito |
Submission information | |
---|---|
Preprint Link: | scipost_202502_00012v1 (pdf) |
Date submitted: | Feb. 7, 2025, 6:40 p.m. |
Submitted by: | Liquito, Raul |
Submitted to: | SciPost Physics |
Ontological classification | |
---|---|
Academic field: | Physics |
Specialties: |
|
Approaches: | Theoretical, Computational |
Abstract
Higher-order topological insulators are an intriguing new family of topological states that host lower-dimensional boundary states. Concurrently, quasiperiodic systems have garnered significant interest due to their complex localization and topological properties. In this work we study the impact of quasiperiodic modulations on the paradigmatic Benalcazar-Bernevig-Hughes model, which hosts topological insulating phases with zero-energy corner modes. We find that the topological properties are not only robust to the quasiperiodic modulation, but can even be enriched. In particular, we unveil the first instance of a quasiperiodic induced second-order topological insulating phase. Furthermore, in contrast with disorder, we find that quasiperiodic modulations can induce multiple reentrant topological transitions, showing an intricate sequence of localization properties. Our results open a promising avenue for exploring the rich interplay between higher-order topology and quasiperiodicity.
Author indications on fulfilling journal expectations
- Provide a novel and synergetic link between different research areas.
- Open a new pathway in an existing or a new research direction, with clear potential for multi-pronged follow-up work
- Detail a groundbreaking theoretical/experimental/computational discovery
- Present a breakthrough on a previously-identified and long-standing research stumbling block
Current status:
Reports on this Submission
Report #2 by Anton Akhmerov (Referee 2) on 2025-4-2 (Contributed Report)
- Cite as: Anton Akhmerov, Report on arXiv:scipost_202502_00012v1, delivered 2025-04-02, doi: 10.21468/SciPost.Report.10956
Strengths
Weaknesses
- Relatively limited discussion and interpretation.
- Numerical evidence sometimes indirect.
Report
Disclaimer: I am providing this report while also acting as the editor in charge of the manuscript.
Quasi-periodic Hamiltonians are at a boundary between ordered and disordered, and they combine features of both. For example, they can have both polynomially and exponentially localized wave functions, as well as approximately metallic bands.
The author consider the impact of quasi-periodicity on the topological properties of the BBH model. There are multiple ways to interpret the properties of this model:
- One can consider it a model with corner charges and no chiral symmetry
- One can consider it a model with chiral symmetry and sublattice-polarized zero modes
In both cases, the literature distinguishes the model as being protected by a C4 symmetry, or two mirror symmetries. The model with chiral symmetry and C4 is a higher order topological phase.
Quasi-periodic modulation of the hoppings, as done in the manuscript, preserves chiral symmetry, and breaks all spatial symmetries, except on average. There is a significant body of literature demonstrating that average symmetries of disordered ensembles are in many ways similar to the exact ones, and in particular a recent Ref. https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.01883 provides a broad framework for those phases.
Let me now turn to the observations of the manuscript. While the authors use the corner charge description, demonstrating that would require breaking chiral symmetry which otherwise provides a much stronger protection.
In systems with chiral symmetry, a sufficiently strong disorder often results in a metallic phase, sometimes known as Gade-Wegner model.
The authors claim: 1. The appearance of a reentrant phase with corner states (the analog of corner charges with chiral symmetry). 2. The coexistence of this reentrant phase with gapless edge states.
These claims are both plausible and interesting. The first claim is plausible because periodic modulation of the hoppings results in Brillouin zone folding, and the appearance of minigaps. It is interesting because an alternative scenario would be that the metallic phase appears before gap reopening. The second claim is plausible because: - The edges have a different Hamiltonian than the bulk due to lattice termination. - A disordered 1D system in this symmetry class may have a localized phase with or without a peak in the density of states or a critical point in conductance. A quasicrystalline phase is likely to inherit some of these properties. - The closing of the edge gap does not change the topological properties because the bulk is an intrinsic higher order TI.
In summary, I believe the paper presents an interesting observation of a quasiperiodic topological phase, which may be used in follow-up research.
Requested changes
- Clarify that the result applies to the sublattice-symmetric system, a higher order TI. Alternatively demonstrates that the conclusions also hold with sublattice symmetry breaking, but this seems to be much harder.
- Fix the colorbar of the FIg. 1b to include the log in the label.
- Consider using a different colormap in the plots for easier readability (see e.g. https://bids.github.io/colormap/ for a further explanation)
- Consider including some of the context described in the report.
Recommendation
Ask for minor revision
Strengths
2 - Robust Methods to study the phenomenon
Weaknesses
Report
However, I am still of the opinion that the shortcomings of the observations are still present, and I am not fully convinced that the results shown warrant the interpretation given. The conclusions would be much clearer if the authors would have considered a system that shows a much larger gap size, for instance.
Nonetheless, I think the paper should be published to ignite constructive scientific discussions.
Requested changes
None
Recommendation
Publish (meets expectations and criteria for this Journal)
Author: Raul Liquito on 2025-05-26 [id 5521]
(in reply to Report 2 by Anton Akhmerov on 2025-04-02)Warnings issued while processing user-supplied markup:
Add "#coerce:reST" or "#coerce:plain" as the first line of your text to force reStructuredText or no markup.
You may also contact the helpdesk if the formatting is incorrect and you are unable to edit your text.
Response to referee 2 report Raul Liquito, Miguel Gonçalves, Eduardo V. Castro May 26, 2025
Dear Anton Akhmerov,
First of all we thank you for the interesting remarks. In this document we address the comments, and propose some modifications to the paper.
Kind regards,
The authors.
==============================================================================================================================================
The referee wrote: Clarify that the result applies to the sublattice-symmetric system, a higher order TI. Alternatively demonstrates that the conclusions also hold with sublattice symmetry breaking, but this seems to be much harder.
Indeed we consider the sublattice-symmetric system. To make this more clear we propose some changes to the manuscript.
Minor changes to the abstract: “In this work we study the impact of chiral symmetry preserving quasiperiodic modulations on the paradigmatic Benalcazar-Bernevig-Hughes model, which hosts topological insulating phases with zero-energy sublattice-polarized modes.”
Extended the paragraph after equation 3, to clarify that we treat the model with chiral symmetry and sub lattice-polarized corner modes, and expanded on the symmetries of the model as a function of phase shifts.
The referee wrote: Fix the colorbar of the FIg. 1b to include the log in the label.
Added log to the colorbar of Fig. 1(b).
The referee wrote: Consider using a different colormap in the plots for easier readability (see e.g. https://bids.github.io/colormap/ for a further explanation).
Changed the colormap (plasma) of all density plots.
The referee wrote: Consider including some of the context described in the report.
Extended the discussion of phase shifts at the end of the paragraph that antecedes equation 4, to clarify the role of phase shifts in finite and open boundary systems.
Rewrote the third paragraph of the conclusion to include some of the remarks made in the referee report.
Attachment:
response_referee_2.pdf