SciPost Submission Page
Exceptional points and pseudoHermiticity in real potential scattering
by Farhang Loran and Ali Mostafazadeh
This Submission thread is now published as
Submission summary
Authors (as registered SciPost users):  Ali Mostafazadeh 
Submission information  

Preprint Link:  scipost_202109_00035v2 (pdf) 
Date accepted:  20220225 
Date submitted:  20220114 16:01 
Submitted by:  Mostafazadeh, Ali 
Submitted to:  SciPost Physics 
Ontological classification  

Academic field:  Physics 
Specialties: 

Approach:  Theoretical 
Abstract
We employ a recentlydeveloped transfermatrix formulation of scattering theory in two dimensions to study a class of scattering setups modeled by real potentials. The transfer matrix for these potentials is related to the timeevolution operator for an associated pseudoHermitian Hamiltonian operator $\widehat\boldsymbol{H}$ which develops an exceptional point for a discrete set of incident wavenumbers. We use the spectral properties of this operator to determine the transfer matrix of these potentials and solve their scattering problem. We apply our general results to explore the scattering of waves by a waveguide of finite length in two dimensions, where the source of the incident wave and the detectors measuring the scattered wave are positioned at spatial infinities while the interior of the waveguide, which is filled with an inactive material, forms a finite rectangular region of the space. The study of this model allows us to elucidate the physical meaning and implications of the presence of the real and complex eigenvalues of $\widehat\boldsymbol{H}$ and its exceptional points. Our results reveal the relevance of the concepts of pseudoHermitian operator and exceptional point in the standard quantum mechanics of closed systems where the potentials are required to be real.
Published as SciPost Phys. 12, 109 (2022)
Author comments upon resubmission
We hope that with the changes we have made in our manuscript, it is now suitable for publication in SciPost.
List of changes
We have added comments and new material to Sec. 2 (the line below Eq. 14), Sec. 3 (2nd line below the numbered list on page 8 and Footnote 3), and Sec. 5 (Fig. 3, which demonstrates the behavior of the eigenvalues and exceptional points of the effective Hamiltonian H, and its discussion given below Eq. 112, and Line 4 on page 22), and a new reference (Ref. 40). We have marked all changes made in the manuscript in red.
Submission & Refereeing History
You are currently on this page
Reports on this Submission
Anonymous Report 2 on 2022216 (Invited Report)
 Cite as: Anonymous, Report on arXiv:scipost_202109_00035v2, delivered 20220216, doi: 10.21468/SciPost.Report.4437
Strengths
1  The paper presents a detailed, rigorous derivation of the authors' results
2  It introduces a new approach to scattering theory, dealing with a specific class of 2D potentials
3  It draws a connection between transport properties of systems without gain and loss and the nonHermitian physics of exceptional points
Weaknesses
1  Due to its nature, the paper is highly technical, which makes it sometimes difficult to follow
Report
The authors present a new approach to scattering theory, which applies to a range of twodimensional problems for which the conventional scattering theory does not work. They use this framework to show a connection between transport properties in Hermitian systems and the exceptional points commonly associated with nonHermitian systems, which would otherwise require gain and/or loss. The paper is detailed and selfcontained, but it is highly technical, and it was difficult for me to follow the authors' derivation. However, I believe this is to be expected given the content of the paper and its results.
Given the above, my opinion is that this work does meet the acceptance criteria for publication in SciPost Physics (https://scipost.org/SciPostPhys/about). Specifically, it opens a new pathway in an existing research direction, with clear potential for multipronged followup work.
I have no changes to request, but I do have one question, mostly for the sake of satisfying my own curiosity. I would imagine that it is possible to associate the transfer matrix with an effective timeevolution operator governed by a nonHermitian Hamiltonian also when doing the conventional scattering theory of Lippmann and Schwinger. Do you expect exceptional points to occur also in that case, or would you rather expect them to be a feature of the twodimensional potentials you consider in this work?
Author: Ali Mostafazadeh on 20220216 [id 2211]
(in reply to Report 2 on 20220216)
This referee has also found our work meeting the acceptance criteria for publication in SciPost Physics and requested no changes. (S)he has asked us the following question: “I would imagine that it is possible to associate the transfer matrix with an effective timeevolution operator governed by a nonHermitian Hamiltonian also when doing the conventional scattering theory of Lippmann and Schwinger. Do you expect exceptional points to occur also in that case, or would you rather expect them to be a feature of the twodimensional potentials you consider in this work?”
In response to this question, we wish to point out that It is absolutely correct that we can use our approach to deal with the (shortrange) potentials to which the standard scattering theory of Lippmann and Schwinger applies, and that the corresponding effective Hamiltonian will be nonHermitian. Although it is not easy to make general statements about the structure and spectral properties of this Hamiltonian, we expect it to possess exceptional points whenever it has a point spectrum. The study of these exceptional points and their physical implications is an interesting topic for future research. Our work provides the first step towards exploring this topic.
Uwe Guenther on 20220221 [id 2230]
The subsequent conceptual remark was part of an Invited Report finalized 4 hours after the Report deadline (end of the day of 16 Feb 2022) so that the SciPost reporting option was automatically closed and only comments were possible afterwards.
Remark:
On page 2, end of paragraph 2 the authors state:
"The present investigation differs from the earlier works on the physical aspects of exceptional points in that it deals with exceptional points arising in the treatment of a scattering problem for a real potential. In the context of their optical or acoustic realizations, these are exceptional points whose presence does not require active or lossy materials."
This statement can be embedded into a slightly broader conceptual context, having a closer glance at the Feshbach projection technique [r1,r2] as applied to derive from Hermitian setups (Hamiltonians with real potentials) effective nonHermitian setups. This basic technique was used, e.g., to study the hidden subtleties of nuclear shell models [r3] and, in this way, it has been one of the starting points of the earlier investigations of I. Rotter [r4] leading later to her investigations into setups with exceptional points (EPs). Similarly, Feshbachprojected Smatrices have been used as theoretical background for the PRL series of the Darmstadt microwave experimental group around A. Richter [r5,11,r6] as well as in earlier slightly related mathematical studies [r7].
(Implicitly and roughly/conceptually spoken, the Naimark dilation approach of [r8] can be considered as a kind of "inverted Feshbach projection" technique in extending/dilating a given nonHermitian setup into an associated Hermitian setup living in a Hilbert space of higher dimension.)
With regard to the present work, one can observe a strong conceptual analogy to Feshbach projections in the sense that an initial 2Dscattering setup with purely real potential is mapped (roughly spoken "projected") to an effective 1D evolution problem governed by the transfermatrixrelated nonHermitian Hamiltonian. Clearly, the transfer matrix approach described in the present work (and developed in a series of earlier publications of the second author) is a deep novel finding whose importance is in no way diminished by very rough conceptual analogies to Feshbach projection techniques as known since the late 1950s. Rather, it can be identified as another important realization of a deep conceptual scheme which might be dubbed, e.g., a "generalized Feshbachlike dynamical projection" associating to a given higherdimensional Hermitian setup an effective lowerdimensional nonHermitian setup.
[r1] H. Feshbach, Ann. Phys. 5, 357 (1958).
[r2] H. Feshbach, Ann. Phys. 19, 287 (1962).
[r3] C. Mahaux and H.A. Weidenmueller, "Shellmodel approach to nuclear reactions",
(NorthHolland, Amsterdam, 1969).
[r4] I. Rotter, Rep. Prog. Phys. 54, 635 (1991).
[r5] B. Dietz et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 074103 (2007).
[r6] S. Bittner et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 024101 (2012).
[r7] S. Albeverio et al., J. Math. Phys. (N.Y.) 37, 4888 (1996).
[r8] U. Guenther and B.F. Samsonov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 230404 (2008).